General Average Due to a Collision of Vessels: What Should a Cargo Owner Do?
General average amount
$ 3.5 million
Task:
Expanding our geographic footprint into the Caspian basin countries has been, and remains, one of our company’s development goals. That’s why we’re especially pleased that more and more clients from this region are entrusting Interlegal’s specialists with matters on which the success of their business depends.
Late last year our Business Development Manager Denys Stadnichenko once again visited Kazakhstan, where he held a number of meetings. One of them resulted in our next case.
We were approached by the owner of cargo that was on board a vessel which collided with another vessel near the Istanbul Strait. General average was declared and average adjusters were duly nominated.
Work done:
The average adjusters notified the parties of measures to secure the cargo and requested that the Client pay General Average Security in the form of a cash deposit equal to 10% of the cargo’s value (about USD 350,000).
A year after the General Average Security was paid and the cargo released, the average adjustment still hadn’t been drawn up. This left the client with doubts about the legitimacy of the general average declaration and the legal steps to take next.
Interlegal’s specialists provided the Client with a legal opinion on the stages of declaring general average, its criteria, how it differs from particular average, and on the lawfulness of declaring it and of withholding the cargo in this specific case.
Let’s note straight away that international law sets no strict deadline for drawing up an average adjustment. Preparing one usually takes several months, but depending on the complexity of the calculations, the number of parties involved, and delays in providing the adjuster with documents or other information, the process can drag on for a year or more. In our practice we’ve seen cases where the adjustment took 3+ years to prepare.
Taking these and other practical nuances into account, our team developed optimal recommendations for the Client’s next steps.
Since the general average arose from a collision of vessels – a matter of tort law that requires establishing the party at fault and compensating the resulting losses – our first piece of advice to the client was to request the following information/documents from the Adjusters:
– the surveyor’s report on the consequences of the collision;
– the official results of the marine casualty investigation;
– compensation of losses by the party at fault;
– whether there are any court disputes between the shipowners relating to the incident in question.
This information will help the Client both when dealing with the other parties to the case (the shipowner, the charterer, insurers) regarding the losses incurred, and should the matter proceed to arbitration.
Result:
The case is still ongoing, and the Client is still waiting for the average adjustment. Meanwhile, the Interlegal team – junior lawyer Dmytro Karetnikov and leading lawyer Mykyta Kocherba, under the overall supervision of partner Karyna Horova – has carefully studied the circumstances of the case and stands ready to take further action to protect the Client’s interests at the first request.
General average is one of the most complex and confusing areas of maritime law. General average cases are so varied and dizzying that they can stump even experienced maritime arbitrators and average adjusters. Advising on general average requires lawyers to have a deep knowledge not only of international and local law, but also of how these rules apply in practice.
Having worked on general average matters for almost 29 years, Interlegal’s specialists have built up enormous experience that allows them to analyse every such case and help clients as quickly and thoroughly as possible. So if you have any questions about general average, we’ll be happy to help resolve them, whether through a standalone consultation or comprehensive legal support on a specific case.