The third is the charm! Large bulker fleet operator vs. Shipowner and P&I

14 мая 2019 г.: ru 1 en 38 ноября 2019 г.: ru 1 en 111 сентября 2020 г.: ru 1 en 1 всего: 9511.01.16


In December 2013, in the process of loading, one of the largest Time Charterer’s vessel collided with another vessel during the latter’s maneuvering. It was risky to continue voyage.

On the collision date, the Time Charterer notified the Voyage Charterer on the vessel’s further voyage only after the necessary repair works at one of the Ukrainian shiprepair yards. But four days later the Voyage Charterer cancelled the Charter Party and the Client applied to Interlegal.

It was a complicated case, unprecedented for Ukraine, with the shortest terms.

Solution search

Case was complicated by absence of clear repair term and impossibility to search for another cargo in view of market situation. First, in order to defend the Client’s interests, Interlegal lawyers initiated court proceedings in Ilyichevsk and applied on arrest of the vessel being liable for accident. The lawyers insisted on claim amount of 2 million USD.

Despite it occurred in late week, three days later (including weekends) the Ilyichevsk local court issued an Order on ship arrest.


Neither shipowners nor their insurers expected for such scenario. But, with regards to legal purity of the Claimant’s actions and significance of the vessel idle stay costs, having consulted to the lawyers, they decided that further court proceedings were unreasonable and proposed amicable dispute settlement.

The Claimant agreed with the Defendants’ proposal. The Parties signed amicable agreement on the Charterer’s loss recovery, followed by immediate claim withdrawal and vessel release.
The Client’s losses were reimbursed seven days after collision.

Our principles of cooperation with clients do not allow us to disclose company names and other confidential information.

  • Notice of Readiness and Demurrage: Geographical Issues in the LMAA Arbitration Award2017.04.20

    Geographical location is one of the principal specifications used for seaport formation having a direct impact on port operation e...

    show more
  • Automatic application of LMAA Small Claims Procedure: to apply or not to apply?2017.02.22

    In 1989 London Maritime Arbitrators Association (LMAA) first introduced the Small Claim Procedure (SCP), construed for consideration of...

    show more
  • Cargo Shortage Fines – Turkey2016.08.01

    We set our advice regarding the Cargo shortage fines imposed by the Turkish Custom in respect of short delivery. When cargo is short-deli...

    show more
  • Commercial Court Practice upon Ship Arrest in Ukraine2016.10.27

    Having studied the Ukrainian court practice regarding ship arrest, we have detected issues of correction and legal gaps the judges faced dur...

    show more
  • Enforcement of commercial (maritime) foreign arbitral awards in Ukraine2016.08.06

    Resolution of maritime disputes by international commercial arbitration is a typical situation in a modern globalized world. Under the refer...

    show more
  • Maritime Law2015.02.10

    Ukraine is a maritime state on the Black Sea and Azov Sea coasts, which has its own fleet, shipbuilding and ship repair facilities, 18 sea p...

    show more
  • Maritime law in Ukraine2014.06.30

    The brief review of maritime law   Ukraine is a maritime state on Black sea and Azov Sea coasts, which has its own fleet, shipbui...

    show more