Interlegal lawyers succeeded in demurrage recovery at the loading port under FOB contract in the framework of GAFTA Arbitration

26 октября 2018 г.: ru 36 en 229 октября 2018 г.: ru 7 en 131 октября 2018 г.: ru 3 en 1 всего: 122 26.10.18

The Seller under FOB contract did not recognize its obligations on demurrage payment at the loading port, since the Buyer replaced the vessel without pre-advice upon the substitute vessel. In the process of contract performance, the Buyer nominated the vessel and provided arranged pre-advice to the Seller.

Vessel nomination complied with contractual terms and the vessel should have arrived within the agreed delivery period. Later, the Buyer replaced the vessel several times, always within the agreed delivery period and with almost the same ETA for each substitute vessel.

When the vessel engaged in actual contract performance arrived at the loading port, the Seller declared on non-readiness for loading, inter alia, due to vessel queue at the sea port. Demurrage arose due to delay in loading.

GAFTA Arbitration ordered that the Buyer’s obligation on pre-advice shall apply to the initial vessel only, and the Buyer is not obliged to provide pre-advice upon the substitute vessel which arrived within the delivery period and with the same ETA that the initial vessel.

In fact GAFTA Arbitration Award corresponds to ideas of the Association which amended the Nomination Clause on September 1, 2017, under which the Buyer’s obligations on pre-advice shall apply to the initial vessel only. The Buyer is not obliged to provide pre-advice in case of replacing vessel, if the substitute vessel arrives at the loading port not earlier than the first vessel’s ETA stated in pre-advice and within the delivery period set forth in the contract.
The Buyer’s claims were satisfied in full.

Interlegal paralegal Alexandr Zhuravskiy, junior lawyer Igor Derus, under the general supervision of senior lawyer Ekaterina Gadetskaya, leading expert in international trade and arbitration, led the case.

  • Interlegal proved unlawfulness of penalty accrual for late return of earnings2019.07.16

    Interlegal represented interests of its Client – large Ukrainian ship repair yard – under the court proceedings on recognizing as unlawful a...

    show more
  • Lawyers of Interlegal successfully settled a dispute over recovery of damages incurred due to collision of vessels2019.07.01

    Client, a foreign shipowner, contacted Interlegal with a request to recover damages incurred as a result of collision of vessels. Circums...

    show more
  • Interlegal consulted the client upon seafarers’ salary taxation2019.07.01

    The client applied to Interlegal for legal advice upon salary taxation for seafarers – citizens of Ukraine receiving salaries from the forei...

    show more
  • Interlegal lawyers defended the Shipowner’s interests during PSC inspection2019.06.24

    The Client, large foreign shipowner, applied to Interlegal on representing its interests during PSC inspection upon compliance with internat...

    show more
  • Consulting upon tax system in Switzerland2019.06.21

    Interlegal corporate lawyers consulted the client upon tax system in Switzerland and foreign citizen employment at Swiss companies. Each...

    show more
  • Interlegal team succeeded in defense of the Charterer’s interests under the dispute on demurrage2019.06.21

    The Client – Charterer applied to Interlegal due to the Shipowner’s unlawful claims on demurrage recovery. In the process of loading and...

    show more
  • Interlegal lawyers drafted the Settlement Agreement due to breach of the Supply Contract by the Counteragent2019.06.05

    The Client, large Ukrainian elevator, filed a request to Interlegal on drafting the Settlement Agreement due to breach of the Supply Contrac...

    show more
  • Interlegal lawyers drafted business inheritance scheme for the client2019.05.27

    The client applied to Interlegal for its business inheritance scheme. Since the business corporate structure includes, inter alia, non-re...

    show more
  • Interlegal expansion in Best Lawyers rating2019.05.24

    Two Interlegal partners joined the Ukrainian top lawyers in Best Lawyers rating. Arthur Nitsevych confirmed his high positions in three n...

    show more
  • Interlegal drafted crew-manned vehicle lease agreement2019.05.21

    The Client, large Romanian forwarder, applied to Interlegal upon drafting crew-manned vehicle lease agreement. It should be noted that th...

    show more